Why the Difference Between the Genealogies of Jesus in Matthew and Luke?



Many people, like me, have wondered why there is such a striking difference between the two genealogies of Jesus Christ found in the books of Matthew and Luke. The differences appear right after King David. In Matthew, David begat Solomon, while in Luke, David is the father of Nathan. From that point on, the two genealogies differ all the way down to Jesus. I found an explanation for this in the book The Messiah by pastor Tony Alamo. I reproduce here the section that answers the problem of the genealogies (translated from the French edition), and I warmly recommend reading the whole book, which clearly shows how more than 300 prophecies were fulfilled in Jesus Christ.

Christ's right to the throne of David.

Here is a complex, difficult riddle: so complicated that it will take concentration on the reader's part to follow the problem and its solution - but it will be well worth it.
The Christ, the descendant of David, must be born of a virgin, and yet have a legal right to the throne of David, despite the fact that one of Solomon's descendants was a wicked man called Jeconiah, of whom it was written that none of his descendants would ever reign in Judah (see Jeremiah 22:28-30), and despite the fact that in Israel the right to the throne was passed down only through the male line. And yet the Christ was born of a virgin!

It is perfectly clear that the Messiah will inherit “the throne of David” (Isaiah 9:7; Jeremiah 33:15-17; Psalm 132:11; 1 Chronicles 17:11, 14). But since he was to be born of a virgin, how can he obtain his legal right to the throne of David? And how can the barrier built by the sin of Jehoiachin be got around? Who can untangle these apparently confusing prophecies, if not the Master Spirit who created these strange prophecies and planned their fulfillment? Remember, the prophet Isaiah declared: “The zeal of the LORD of hosts will perform this” (Isaiah 9:7).

Not only was what seemed impossible to resolve resolved by Jesus Christ, but God has also given us the whole account of how he did it in the genealogies of the New Testament. In Matthew's, the genealogy of Christ through Joseph is given. This genealogy shows that Christ is the son of David - thus giving him the right to the throne of David - and also “the son of Abraham” - giving him the right to the Promised Land, possession of the territories given to Abraham and his seed (It is interesting to note that in Luke 3:38 the genealogy of Christ is traced through Heli (Mary's father) all the way to Adam and God - thus giving Christ the title deed to the whole earth as “son of Adam” (see Genesis 1:27-30; Hebrews 2:6-9; Revelation 5:1-10), and to “all things” as “Son of God” (see Hebrews 1:2)).

In Matthew's genealogy, Joseph comes from the ROYAL line of King David through Solomon. But Joseph is also a descendant of David through Jehoiachin (also called Coniah) - so succession to the throne through Joseph is ruled out. Matthew's genealogical record takes care to show that Jesus was not, through Joseph, “the fruit of David's body”, that is, a direct descendant of David through Joseph.

In the Gospel of Luke 3:23-38, the genealogy of Christ is given through Mary. Heli was clearly Mary's father, Joseph's father-in-law, verse 23 (It is interesting to note that in Matthew's genealogical record it is written that “Jacob begat Joseph” (Matthew 1:16), that is, Jacob was Joseph's real father. But in Luke's account it is written that Joseph was “the son of Heli” (Luke 3:23), a son in the sense that he was married to Heli's daughter. This agrees with Jewish custom (see 1 Samuel 24:16). In this record, Christ is described as the literal “fruit of David's body” through his mother Mary. But, and this is important, although Mary came from a ROYAL line, that of David, she had no right to the throne, because she was descended from King David through Nathan, while the rights to the throne had to come through Solomon's line (see 1 Chronicles 28:5). So the marriage of Joseph to Mary before the birth of Christ was an absolute necessity - and that is exactly what happened!

“Now the birth of Jesus Christ was on this wise: When as his mother Mary was espoused to Joseph, before they came together, she was found with child of the Holy Ghost... behold, the angel of the Lord appeared unto him in a dream, saying, Joseph, thou SON OF DAVID, fear not to take unto thee Mary THY WIFE: for that which is conceived in her is of the Holy Ghost” Matthew 1:18-20 (It is a mistake to minimize the importance of the Bible's genealogical records. They are very important for showing that Jesus of Nazareth is the MESSIAH and that he has the right to the throne of David. The presence of genealogical records in the New Testament also shows the importance God places on the PROOF that Jesus is the Son of David, and indirectly shows the importance of reasoning based on the fulfillment of prophecy).

So, through Mary, Jesus Christ obtained his direct descent from King David, and through Mary's marriage to Joseph, who was also a “son of David”, he obtained the legal right to the throne of David, because Mary was Joseph's wife before Jesus was born, which makes Joseph the legal father of Jesus, his adoptive father. And so the prophecy about Jeconiah was fulfilled too, because Jesus Christ is NOT the “seed” - a direct descendant - of Jeconiah. Can you think of anything more complicated, and yet resolved with such precision?

Joseph and Mary had to be the parents (adoptive father and mother) of Jesus Christ; they were the only two of that generation who could be, thus fulfilling the prophecy of the Messiah. And Joseph had to be married to Mary before Jesus was born so that he would obtain his legal right to the throne of David through Joseph. At the same time, Christ could not be Joseph's child because of the prohibition against Jeconiah's descendants. And although Joseph had to be married to Mary, Joseph could nevertheless not “know” Mary as his wife until after Jesus was born, because he had to be born of a virgin! And the divinely ordained fulfillment was perfect in every detail!

Tony Alamo, The Messiah

You can read the whole of this 95-page book, showing how more than 300 prophecies were fulfilled in Jesus, by clicking on this sentence.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Restoration

Putting the Devil Out of Work

Making God Fashionable?